Are Vancouver millennials being screwed as badly as those in Toronto? Turns out not quite as hard, but it’s still pretty bad. Over the past 15 years, the average Vancouver household income grew just 10.75%, while housing grew *drumroll* 172% (inflation adjusted). Incase you missed it, Toronto’s housing prices grew 188%, while the median income grew just 0.38% – that’s right, less than a percent.
Recommended Income
Most experts recommend a home that’s approximately 3-4 times your income. So we thought we would do a quick check to see where those income levels would be. Turns out you would need a family income of $318,275, a whopping 322% rise over today’s income. Call us pessimistic (it’s the Millennial in us), but we don’t see that happening next year. Feel free to remember this point the next time you hear about how “robust” the economy is.
How Did You Get Your Numbers?
A common practice in finance is to use inflation accounting, adjusting all numbers to the dollar value of a single year. We adjusted those numbers using the Bank of Canada’s official rate to 2016 dollars. Housing data was courtesy of the GVREB, and we used January as the baseline. StatsCan only provides data up to 2013, so the 2015-2016 income levels were estimates we arrived at by analyzing the previous years. Some banks, like Royal Bank, have estimated that the median income in Vancouver during year of 2015 was as low as $63,000.
Not so fun fact (and why we sometimes use estimates):
Have you ever heard a politician talk about our robust economy and you were thinking ‘what the hell are they talking about?’ That’s because those nifty census forms you fill out take up to 5 years to process. The most recent data for things like income are 2013 – just think about that for a second. Uber was just a limo company, SnapChat was just founded in someone’s dorm, and no one knew what the hell ISIS was…so you’ll have to forgive us if in 5 years you find there was a minor statistical variance from our 2016 numbers. We try to move faster than the speed of government.
Sources: GVREB, StatsCan, Better Dwelling Inc.
Let’s have an honest discussion about real estate.
Like us on Facebook and we’ll let you know when the next post goes live.
This comparison, suggesting that Toronto’s inflation-adjusted price increases are similar to Vancouver’s, are wrong. For some reason, the Vancouver calculation is based on the last 15 years (172%), while for Toronto, they go back 30 years (188%). Go back 30 years in Vancouver (to include the pre-HK-handover price boom) and the number will probably make your eyeballs explode.
Almost all numbers regarding Vancouver make my eyes want to explode.
[…] they didn’t put statistics to those statements, we recently published an article that showed Vancouver’s home prices have risen 172 per cent in the last 15 years, while income has only moved up 10 per cent. The struggle in VanCity is […]
[…] interest rates were slashed. Except, that’s not the case. Income has been stagnant in both Vancouver and Toronto, with many people making less than they did in previous years. This leaves market […]
[…] Over the past year wages in BC have fallen 2.7% when inflation adjusted. In the booming economy of Vancouver, wages have only increased 10% over the past 15 years when inflation adjusted. With that in mind, it’s not hard to be skeptical of how adding another […]
[…] As pointed out by betterdwelling.com, boasting the most expensive real estate in Canada, BC also has one of the lowest median incomes in the country. Even in its largest, wealthiest city, income has only moved up 10% while Vancouver’s home prices have risen 172% in the last 15 years. […]
[…] up and interest rates were slashed. Except, that’s not the case. Income has been stagnant in both Vancouver and Toronto, with many people making less than they did in previous years. This leaves market […]