One of the banking industry’s biggest secrets is one that typically only drug dealers, terrorists, and people evading capital controls ever use – smurfing. Smurfing, sometimes known as structuring, is the process of breaking down money into small amounts to avoid regulatory scrutiny, before transferring said money to a safe haven. Unfortunately, there’s a good chance Vancouver and Toronto’s real estate markets are getting caught in the middle of this, and there’s mounting evidence the big 5 banks are knowingly assisting.
Smurfing In China (Capital Exports Explained)
China has capital export limits that prohibit any individual from exporting more than US$50,000 per person, per year. Think about that for a minute. The benchmark price for a home in Vancouver is $1,513,800, which makes the minimum down payment $302,760 – roughly $228,409 Canadian dollars more than can be exported from China at today’s exchange rate. As shocking as that is, it became mind blowing when National Bank’s Peter Routledge estimated that 33% of Vancouver’s homes are being sold to foreign buyers from China – which would require an awful lot of smurfs.
What Does My Bank Have To Do With It
The first thing you need to know is that smurfing can’t happen without a lot of people opening a lot of bank accounts. In 2014 a little light was shed when a wrongful dismissal suit (Ogden v. CIBC) went to the BC Supreme Court. The details of the case read like a drama, but this jewel of information was said in passing “a CIBC client wanted to send $150,000 from China to Canada, the money had to come from three accounts belonging to three different account holders in China and be transferred to three separate accounts belonging to three separate account holders in Canada.”
Fun fact, Ogden was awesome at bringing foreign money into Canada, bringing in an estimated “$60,000,000” in Canadian mortgages for overseas investors at her branch.
So while Canadian banks aren’t breaking any laws, they aren’t exactly following all of China’s laws either. When a Chinese investor want a mortgage in Canada, some bank employees will explain that in order to get around the Chinese export laws, they will need to find several people, and have them each open a Canadian bank account. Each one of them will then receive up to a USD$50,000 wire transfer from a smurf in China. Once a sufficient amount of money has been exported from China via the smurfs, the money from each account is amalgamated into the investor’s Canadian account. This is a loophole that allows Chinese money to flow into the Canadian real estate market in a short time, while not technically breaking any laws in Canada. Here’s another great quote pulled from the trial transcript:
“each individual was restricted to transferring no more than $50,000 USD abroad annually out of China. Working around these regulations was a challenge and a complicated process, but it was a practice CIBC supported.”
— Ogden v. CIBC:164
But Chinese Investors WANT Canadian real estate
An interesting narrative that’s being told is that Canadian real estate is a great investment, which is why it’s attracting so many investors to Vancouver and Toronto. Turns out when you look at the yuan value of homes in Toronto over the past 5 years, the average real estate investor would have realized a loss of 1.82%. That’s right, a loss. This excludes closing costs and mortgage interest, which would have made it even worse.
So just how much money?
Capital fleeing China has been an accelerating problem, with an estimated $504 billion in the second half of 2015. Goldman Sachs revealed in a research note on Monday that by their estimate, 70% of the net outflows were from individuals buying foreign assets like real estate. This has been showing up most notably in markets like Vancouver, Sydney, and London. Goldman further revealed that the first quarter showed an estimated $123 billion fled, up almost 13% from the year before. So while the market may appear to be crazy right now, it might actually get crazier in the second half.
China’s capital flow month by month. Source: State Administration of Foreign Exchange, People’s Republic of China and the People’s Bank of China, Better Dwelling
What Happens Next
It’s important to note that the originating capital in China likely isn’t from some nefarious source, they’re mostly just average millionaires seeking a lower tax jurisdiction for their money. Smurfing isn’t a problem for Canada if we’re just winning some sort of lottery where the wealthiest people in the world all of a sudden decided they want to actually live in the houses they are purchasing here. Afterall, the more the merrier!
However, if these investors are using our homes as a midway point to get their cash to an offshore haven, they’re really just inflating our home prices – making it harder for Canadians to purchase homes. These inflated homes would then have to be passed person to person in what Marc Cohodes explained earlier this week, is “a Ponzi”.
Canadians who have purchased homes at inflated prices might be in an even worse situation if China decides to crack down on export laws, stopping the inflow of money to our real estate market. If this happens it will force fire sales and foreclosures, sending inventory skyrocketing. This will leave a large number of Canadians carrying mortgages on overpriced homes. If you’re thinking the foreign investors are just as likely to lose money as you are, you might want to revisit that thoguht. Our banks can seamlessly move the money from Canada to one of their offshore branches like TD Bermuda, CIBC First Caribbean, BMO Cayman, Scotiabank Cayman Islands, and RBC Cayman.
Open immigration is one of the things that makes Canada a great place to live, just ask our founder who’s family immigrated here not all that long ago. In fact, Toronto and Vancouver are vibrant multi-cultural cities because of our liberal immigration policies. The majority of people immigrating here are likely moving here for legitimate purposes… but there’s 10,800 empty homes in Vancouver that might indicate we have a bit of a smurfing problem.
Let’s have an honest discussion about real estate.
Like us on Facebook and we’ll let you know when the next post goes live.
Wow, the down payment math definitely makes it crystal clear this is mass fraud.
Aren’t we suppose to have the safest banks in the world? What the hell!
I think the real question here is… Does Canada or China plan on doing anything about this? If not, there’s not much we can do.
There’s not a lot China can do about it, Canada’s free trade agreement prohibits China from nationalizing any assets located in Canada. We pretty much crafted a trade deal explicitly for this purpose, then we make fun of the fluster Chinese minister to draw attention away from how bad the deal was.
I’m not sure why the Canadian mainstream media is constantly patting themselves on the back for taking the bait our government throws them for distractions.
We should not care too much how the money is getting here. It is what the money is doing when arriving.
Immigrant Investors to Canada should be forced to open legitimate businesses that support our economy not destroy the housing market and turn it into a wild futures market.
Same with all incoming investment.
Easily done if you simply co-ordinate taxation with real estate records.
If the purchaser does not have a reasonable tax Nexus in Canada then their property becomes a business and subject to capital gains tax and it should be a 50% tax for foreign real estate owners.
We have senators with husbands stashing millions off shore, reporters with 10s of millions of dollars in property (which doesn’t even make sense unless, hm…), and a banking system designed to filter money into offshore havens. You really think we’re going to go after foreign money?
If you walk along Coal harbor at 9:00 to 11:00 when 80% of all apartment lights are usually on, you will see that most of the buildings are 80 to 90% dark. This represents parked money just like a bank. However if you are searching for a rental in Vancouver you will find nothing at a reasonable rate.
I support a dark window tax of 50% of reasonable rental value.
If you do not live here than you are not spending $50,000.00 a year in the local economy, restaurants, shops, haircuts,etc. Just because you pay your property tax does not give you the right to park money in our precious real estate and take up the space.
People must get it into their heads that real estate is for Living, not for Speculation.
I’m not sure I understand why such individuals would like to learn your lesson? Wouldn’t it not benefit them at all and force them to pay a tax?
It’s great to want to teach people a lesson, but foolish not to recognize how unlikely they would learn such a lesson.
Off the top of my head, I have this analogy. What if you made 20% return on your mutual funds, say you bought a Britain Based Fund. Analogous to your proposal, the British government should ask you to return another 50% of your after tax earnings because you don’t run a British business and have no business profiting from them.
I heard omega 3 is good for the brain.
With your logic foreign students should not be paying a premium when they do their post secondary education here in Canada. Post secondary education is considered an investment too.
There is a good reason to protect the real estate market in Canada. You compare different markets and different type investments. You have to also consider private and public goods and trading .
[…] bubble is a lot different from the rest of Canada. They have money laundering, shadow flipping, and have had artificial building restraints until recently. It’s sexy to […]
[…] Smurfing, or structuring, is one of the most effective ways of moving money to Canada – it’s also a method popular with drug dealers, and human traffickers. Large amounts of cash are broken down into deposits small enough to not attract regulatory scrutiny. That cash is then assembled into a single account, or used to pay a mortgage. While it sounds complicated, it’s not. Heck, Canadian banks will even help you figure it out. […]
[…] Smurfing, or structuring, is one of the most effective ways of moving money to Canada — it’s also a method popular with drug dealers and human traffickers. Large amounts of cash are broken down into deposits small enough to not attract regulatory scrutiny. That cash is then assembled into a single account or used to pay a mortgage. While it sounds complicated, it’s not. Heck, Canadian banks will even help you figure it out. […]
[…] Smurfing, or structuring, is one of the most effective ways of moving money to Canada — it’s also a method popular with drug dealers and human traffickers. Large amounts of cash are broken down into deposits small enough to not attract regulatory scrutiny. That cash is then assembled into a single account or used to pay a mortgage. While it sounds complicated, it’s not. Heck, Canadian banks will even help you figure it out. […]
[…] street goons. Police forces around the world allege they do everything, from drug trafficking to smurfing. Although they do have much more legitimate operations, like making movies and real estate […]
[…] street goons. Police forces around the world allege they do everything, from drug trafficking to smurfing. Although they do have much more legitimate operations, like making movies and real estate […]
[…] buyers engage in the same technique that drug dealers, human traffickers, and counterfeiters do, smurfing. Smurfing is when a large amount of capital is broken down into smaller, more discrete amounts. […]
[…] Smurfing is a controversial process where a large amount of money is wired in small sums. These sums are designed to be small enough to avoid the scrutiny of financial regulators. People get family, friends, strangers for a fee, underground banks, etc. to transfer the money to separate bank accounts abroad. Those separate bank accounts are then assembled into a downpayment. The process repeats until you run out of money or the house is yours. It’s a soft-form of money laundering, but the money isn’t necessarily ill-gotten. Since there’s nothing to demonstrate the money is from the proceeds of crime, the Canadian government is more than happy to have the money flow in to Canada. […]
[…] Smurfing is a controversial process where a large amount of money is wired in small sums. These sums are designed to be sufficiently small to keep away from the scrutiny of economic regulators. Folks get household, associates, strangers for a price, underground banks, and many others. to switch the cash to separate financial institution accounts overseas. These separate financial institution accounts are then assembled right into a downpayment. The method repeats till you run out of cash or the home is yours. It’s a soft-form of cash laundering, however the cash isn’t essentially ill-gotten. Since there’s nothing to reveal the cash is from the proceeds of crime, the Canadian authorities is more than pleased to have the cash movement in to Canada. […]
[…] Are Smurfs and Canadian Banks Ruining The Canadian Real Estate Market? => https://betterdwelling.com/are-smurfs-and-canadian-banks-ruining-the-canadian-real-estate-market/ […]
[…] We’ve talked about China’s capital controls quite a few times, but in case you missed it here’s a brief intro. Chinese citizens are limited to exporting US$50,000 per person, per year. Not even enough to make a down payment on a house in Vancouver. So friends, family, strangers for money would lend their quotas to other people, so they could do a form of “soft” money laundering called smurfing. […]
[…] done a whole write up on how smurfing works, but the gist is you borrow other people’s capital allowance. This increases your US$50,000 […]
[…] a bank known for aggressively pursuing foreign buyers, is the first bank to roll out new foreign income checks. With other banks likely to follow, […]
[…] CIBC是一家以积极吸引外国买家而闻名的银行，现在也是第一家推出国外收入审核制度的银行。与他银行极有可能跟进效仿，外国资金面临在银行贷款购房的新障碍。OSFI B-20规定外加中国资本管制，两者加起来可能比非居民炒房税更有效。 […]
[…] Smurfing is a controversial process where a large amount of money is wired in small sums. These sums are designed to be small enough to avoid the scrutiny of financial regulators. People get family, friends, strangers for a fee, underground banks, etc. to transfer the money to separate bank accounts abroad. Those separate bank accounts are then assembled into a downpayment. The process repeats until you run out of money or the house is yours. It’s a soft-form of money laundering, but the money isn’t necessarily ill-gotten. Since there’s nothing to demonstrate the money is from the proceeds of crime, the Canadian government is more than happy to have the money flow in to Canada. […]
[…] corrupt Chinese officials.” Canada is easy to immigrate to, and up until recently banks would even knowingly help you circumvent your country’s capital controls. The only catch is you need a good reason, like buying a home. It shouldn’t be a big surprise to […]
Assalam-o-Aleikum
I want to use this opportunity to Invite you to the Zabeel Investments PJSC project Loan programme. Do you have any lucrative project that requires loan funding? What’s the sector of the project? Do you think the project can generate a good ROI? let me know your interest for more details via my below email address.
Thank you as I look forward to your reply.
Regards,
Divyesh Mahajan
Business consultant with Zabeel investments PJSC ,Please kindly reply on this email.: [email protected]